Buffalo Cheddar Cheese

Keystone Cheese was founded in 2014 by Nikole Raskovic in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Family visits to Wisconsin introduced her to regional cheeses she wanted to bring home to Pennsylvania. The woman-founded business grew from a small office and garage into a specialty-food company working with small Wisconsin cheesemakers, with an emphasis on distinctive flavors, traditional craftsmanship and relationships with family farms.

Buffalo Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar includes a blend of peppers for a buffalo-inspired flavor. Suggested use: melt onto a sandwich or use in a game-day cheese dip. Made in Wisconsin, United States.

For a tasting, cut a small portion first and pair it with a plain cracker or piece of bread before adding stronger accompaniments. For cooking, add a measured amount to a familiar recipe so the cheese complements the other ingredients. Aged, fresh, smoked and seasoned cheeses behave differently; choose this specific style for the flavor and texture described here.

Explore American-made cheese selections and American-made food and pantry products for related choices on buyamerican.mom. Each linked product has its own specifications and availability.

Highlights & Uses

• Selection: Buffalo Cheddar Cheese
• Character: Cheddar includes a blend of peppers for a buffalo-inspired flavor.
• Serving or use idea: Melt onto a sandwich or use in a game-day cheese dip.
• Format: 6oz.; 7oz.; 8oz.; 9oz.; 10oz.
• Origin: Made in Wisconsin, United States.

Size, Options & Origin

• Brand or supplier: Keystone Cheese; named product brands are identified in the title where relevant.
• Supplied format: 6oz.; 7oz.; 8oz.; 9oz.; 10oz.
• Country of origin: United States
• Origin detail: Wisconsin, United States

Hand-cut cheese weights can vary slightly. Select the specific listed weight before ordering; the package label identifies the net quantity supplied. Where a stock photograph shows a different nominal weight, use the selected option and confirm the current package specification before purchase.

Ingredients & Allergen Information

Published ingredients: pasteurized milk, cayenne, habanero pepper, salt, jalapeno pepper, red pepper, annatto color (when applicable), enzymes, cultures

Ingredient or variant allergens identified: Milk. This is not a claim that other allergens or cross-contact are absent.

Recipes and subingredients can change. The delivered package's ingredient and allergen statements must be checked for the selected flavor and size. The FDA guide to reading food-allergy labels explains how to read ingredient and advisory statements.

Care, Shipping & Returns

Keep this food refrigerated according to its package instructions. Inspect the seal, condition and temperature promptly on arrival, then follow the current use-by and after-opening directions. For products labeled Keep Refrigerated, do not taste a shipment that arrives warm or in a questionable condition; contact BuyAmerican with the order number and photographs. See the USDA guidance for receiving mail-order foods for arrival checks.

Shipping for This Product

Keystone's published dispatch schedule avoids weekend transit: orders placed after 1 p.m. Eastern on Wednesday are scheduled for the following Monday. Transit may take up to four days after shipment, depending on destination, weather and seasonal delays. Temperature-sensitive orders may need additional insulation, expedited service or a weather hold. A street address is required; the supplier excludes P.O. boxes. Shipping charges and any applicable supplier offer must be confirmed at checkout.

Returns for This Product

BuyAmerican's standard return policy excludes perishable food. Report damage, defects or an incorrect item immediately and retain the packaging and order information. Keystone's product pages state no returns or exchanges except for damaged or defective products; its FAQ describes a 48-hour satisfaction request, while its general refund policy describes a 30-day window. The applicable supplier terms require confirmation before ordering. Do not ship an item back without authorization.

For assistance with a BuyAmerican order, use BuyAmerican customer support and review the BuyAmerican returns and refunds policy.