Moonlit Mischief | 500-Piece New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle

Founded in 2007 by Adam Silver and Sarah Dickinson, New York Puzzle Company is based in Brooklyn, New York. The college friends began with a jigsaw puzzle of the New York City subway map. Their range centers on illustration, classic book art, and nostalgic images chosen to make everyday puzzling engaging. Recycled puzzle board and USA production reflect the company’s focus on thoughtful materials and domestic manufacturing.

Moonlit Mischief | 500-Piece New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle

Moonlit Mischief is a 500-piece jigsaw puzzle with a finished size of 18 × 24 inches. It turns the featured illustration into a tabletop activity for puzzlers aged 10 and up, following the manufacturer’s age recommendation.

Celebrate the playful spirit of Halloween with Moonlit Mischief, a 500-piece puzzle featuring the October 31, 1959 cover of The New Yorker by renowned illustrator William Steig. This whimsical scene captures a moonlit night full of spooky fun, with costumed creatures causing chaos in a leafless tree, and a glowing jack-o’-lantern grinning mischievously from below. With its vintage charm, vivid colors, and festive Halloween energy, this puzzle is a delightful treat for fans of classic cartoons, nostalgic holiday art, and seasonal puzzling.

Use the box illustration as a visual reference and leave room around the finished image for sorting loose pieces. Group recognizable colors, borders, and image details, then connect small sections as the picture takes shape. Work alone or share sections with another suitable puzzler; the image and the puzzler’s experience will influence the pace of assembly.

Key features

• 500-piece jigsaw format.
• Featured artwork: New Yorker Cover by Artist William Steig, originally published on October 31st, 1959.
• Linen-style finish helps reduce glare.
• Manufactured in the USA, according to the maker.

Product specifications

• Piece count: 500
• Finished puzzle size: 18 × 24 inches
• Recommended age: 10 years and up
• Artwork credit: New Yorker Cover by Artist William Steig, originally published on October 31st, 1959
• Country of origin: United States
• SKU: NPZNY2594

Materials and construction

The manufacturer describes its puzzles as thick, 100% recycled chipboard printed with soy-based inks and finished with a linen-style surface to reduce glare. The board gives the image a firm paperboard backing for tabletop assembly, while the lightly textured finish helps keep the printed artwork comfortable to view under ordinary room lighting.

Care and storage

Keep the cardboard pieces and box dry. Handle pieces with clean, dry hands, use a clean tabletop, and avoid drinks or food near the work area. Brush away loose dust gently with a soft, dry cloth. Do not immerse or wet-clean the board. Separate pieces carefully after use and return them to the box for storage away from moisture and direct sunlight. These are practical storage suggestions for a paperboard puzzle; follow any care instructions supplied with your item.

Shipping for this item

For this item, the supplier publishes typical processing of 1–2 business days and dispatch from its warehouse in Greenfield, Indiana. Standard delivery within the contiguous United States is estimated at a further 3–7 business days after dispatch. Processing time and carrier transit are separate, and weekends, holidays, weather, or destination can affect arrival. Available services and shipping charges for your buyamerican.mom order appear at checkout; check delivery needs before ordering for an event or gift date.

Returns for this item

The supplier’s standard return window for this item is 30 days from the initial purchase date. Eligible merchandise must be unopened, with the original shrink wrap or belly band/seal tabs and inner bag intact, as applicable. Return authorization is required before mailing anything. The customer pays return shipping, and original shipping charges are not refundable. Accepted refunds go to the original payment method. Start a buyamerican.mom order request with our customer support team so the correct instructions can be provided.

For delivery questions or an order issue, contact buyamerican.mom customer support with the product name and order number.

Compare more American-made games and puzzles, or browse toys and games for another tabletop activity. When choosing a gift for a child, follow the package age recommendation and the CPSC’s guidance on choosing age-appropriate toys.